Bloody Mary Mixers Compared: Zing Zang vs Fever Tree
By Chicago's Best Wine & Spirits Store | Published: 2026-10-20
Category: Comparisons
Compare three top Bloody Mary mixers: Zing Zang, Fever Tree, and Stirrings. Learn their flavor profiles, price points, and which one fits your brunch style.
Quick answer
For a bold, traditional Bloody Mary with a hint of horseradish, choose Stirrings. If you prefer a smooth, tomato-forward mix that's easy to customize, go with Fever Tree. Zing Zang is your best bet for a classic spicy blend at a budget-friendly price.
Why the mixer matters
The Bloody Mary mix is the backbone of your cocktail. A good mix balances tomato, spice, and acidity, letting your vodka or gin shine. The three options here each take a different approach, so your choice depends on whether you want heat, tang, or a clean tomato base.
Price and value trade-off
Zing Zang is the most affordable at $4.34 for 32 oz, making it a great value for parties. Fever Tree and Stirrings are priced similarly at around $5.50–$5.70 for 750ml, but offer more concentrated flavors. If you're mixing for a crowd, Zing Zang stretches further without sacrificing quality.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Zing Zang 32 oz: America's #1 mix. The 7-vegetable blend is spicy and balanced. Best value for large batches. Great for parties or first-time mixers who want a reliable, no-fuss option.
- Fever Tree 750ml: Tomato-forward with Californian tomatoes. Smooth and less acidic. Pairs well with premium vodka or gin. Choose this if you like a cleaner taste and want to highlight your spirit.
- Stirrings 750ml: Extra horseradish, lemon, and Worcestershire. A little sugar balances the heat. Works with gin or vodka. Ideal for those who want a spicy, tangy Bloody Mary with serious kick.
Product facts
- ZING ZANG BLOODY MARY MIX (32 OZ): Zing Zang uses a distinctive 7-vegetable juice blend and complex seasonings for a unique, bold flavor. This gives you a ready-to-pour mix that's spicy on its own, so you can skip extra seasoning and just add your spirit.
ZING ZANG BLOODY MARY MIX (32 OZ) - FEVER TREE BLOODY MARY MIX, 750ml: Fever Tree Bloody Mary Mix is a 750ml blend of Californian tomatoes and unique spices for a bold and spicy flavor. The tomato-forward base is smooth and less acidic, making it ideal if you want a cleaner canvas for custom garnishes.
FEVER TREE BLOODY MARY MIX, 750ml - STIRRINGS BLOODY MARY MIXER 750ML: Stirrings Bloody Mary Mixer has extra horseradish, lemons, and Worcestershire with a pinch of sugar. That extra horseradish kick adds a sinus-clearing heat that stands up to both vodka and gin, perfect for spice lovers.
Which one fits you?
Best for
- Budget-friendly parties and classic spicy flavor: Zing Zang
- Smooth, tomato-forward base that lets your spirit shine: Fever Tree
- Extra horseradish heat and tangy complexity: Stirrings
Not for
- Those who dislike spicy or horseradish-forward mixes: skip Stirrings
- Anyone looking for a non-tomato-based mixer: all three are tomato-based
