Two Single-Vineyard Cabernets from the Same Vintage
BOND's St Eden and Quella both come from the 2006 Napa Valley vintage, but they offer distinctly different expressions of Cabernet Sauvignon. St Eden leans toward opulent black fruit and new oak, while Quella emphasizes perfume and structure. Understanding these differences—and the evidence behind them—will help you decide which bottle suits your palate or occasion.
St Eden 2006: Opulent Black Fruit and Oak
- BOND ST EDEN 2006, Napa: Stunning black fruits, roasted herbs, sweet cassis, graphite, and new oak. Fleshy and even opulent. These tasting notes describe a rich, forward style of Napa Cabernet that emphasizes fruit intensity and oak influence.

BOND ST EDEN 2006, Napa - BOND ST EDEN 2006, Napa: 92pts - Robert Parker A critic score from Robert Parker provides a benchmark for quality and style preference among collectors.
Quella 2006: Perfumed and Structured
- BOND QUELLA 2006, Napa: Complex, perfumed aromas of ripe cherry, plum and currant. Full-bodied, well-structured wine. Focused and concentrated, with a long, persistent finish. These notes highlight a more aromatic, structured profile that may appeal to those who favor elegance and persistence over sheer opulence.

BOND QUELLA 2006, Napa - BOND QUELLA 2006, Napa: 93pts - Wine Spectator A Wine Spectator score offers an independent assessment of quality and can guide buying decisions.
Flavor and Structure: Opulence vs. Elegance
St Eden and Quella differ in both aromatic expression and palate weight. The choice between them comes down to whether you prefer a fleshier, oak-driven style or a more perfumed, structured one.
- Aromatics: St Eden shows black fruits, roasted herbs, sweet cassis, graphite, and new oak. Quella offers ripe cherry, plum, and currant with perfumed complexity.
- Palate: St Eden is described as fleshy and even opulent. Quella is full-bodied and well-structured, with a focused, concentrated profile.
- Finish: Quella is noted for a long, persistent finish. St Eden's finish is not detailed in the supplied notes, so we cannot compare directly.
Price and Value: What You Pay For
At $292.50 for St Eden and $319.50 for Quella, the price difference is modest—about $27. Both are discounted from a $450 comparison price, representing significant savings. The choice between them should be based on style preference rather than price, as the cost per bottle is relatively close. However, keep in mind that critic scores (92 for St Eden, 93 for Quella) are nearly identical, so neither bottle is objectively 'better' by that measure alone.
How to Choose Between St Eden and Quella
Consider these factors when deciding which 2006 BOND Cabernet to purchase.
- If you love bold, oak-influenced Cabernet: Choose St Eden for its opulent black fruit and new oak character.
- If you prefer aromatic complexity and structure: Choose Quella for its perfumed red-fruit aromas and long finish.
- If you value a higher critic score: Quella holds a 93-point Wine Spectator score, one point above St Eden's 92-point Robert Parker score. Both are highly regarded.
- If you're buying for a special occasion: Both are special-occasion wines, but Quella's structure and persistence may suit formal dinners, while St Eden's opulence can be a crowd-pleaser.
What We Don't Know: Limitations of the Evidence
The supplied product information does not include details on aging potential, decanting recommendations, or food pairing specifics. Additionally, St Eden's finish and Quella's oak treatment are not described. These gaps mean we cannot provide definitive advice on cellaring or serving beyond what is stated. For precise guidance, consult the producer's technical sheets or a wine professional.



